When you purchase a leasehold property, you take on not just a home, but a share of responsibility for the building’s upkeep and associated costs. One significant ongoing expense for leaseholders is building insurance.
However, questions often arise over whether the premiums being charged are fair or necessary. So, how can leaseholders ensure they’re not footing the bill for excessive or avoidable insurance costs?
What Is Included in Building Insurance for Leaseholders?
For most leasehold properties, especially flats or apartments, the freeholder or managing agent arranges building insurance for the entire block. Leaseholders are then charged a portion of the premium through their service charge.
This type of insurance typically covers structural damage, communal areas, plumbing and electrical systems, and sometimes external risks like subsidence or flooding.
While it sounds straightforward, problems arise when insurance policies are overly expensive, include add-ons that provide little value, or are arranged through connected parties that charge inflated commissions.
Why Are Leaseholders Often Overcharged?
Several factors contribute to leaseholders paying more than necessary for insurance. These include:
- Lack of transparency: Leaseholders may not have full access to the insurance policy documents or details of broker fees and commissions.
- Commission incentives: Freeholders or managing agents may receive commissions from insurance brokers, creating a conflict of interest where cost is not the primary consideration.
- Bundled services: Some policies include cover for risks or services not relevant to all leaseholders, such as commercial use cover or high-value contents insurance.
- Lack of competitive tendering: Insurance contracts may be automatically renewed without comparing prices across multiple providers.
How Can Leaseholders Challenge or Review Insurance Charges?
Leaseholders have several legal rights and practical steps they can take to avoid overpaying:
- Request full documentation: Under Section 21 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985, leaseholders can request a summary of the insurance policy and details of any commissions or fees involved. Managing agents are legally obliged to provide this information.
- Compare market rates: Even though leaseholders may not be allowed to purchase the policy themselves, they can still gather quotes for comparable coverage from other providers to assess if the current cost is inflated.
- Form a residents’ association or Right to Manage company: Where possible, leaseholders can join forces to take control of property management and insurance decisions. This often leads to more transparent and cost-effective arrangements.
- Challenge unfair charges via the tribunal: If leaseholders believe that insurance costs are unreasonably high or unjustified, they can apply to a First-tier Tribunal to contest them. While this process may take time and involve legal costs, it has been effective in many cases.
What Should You Look Out for in an Insurance Policy?
Leaseholders reviewing their insurance arrangements should consider:
- The rebuild cost versus the insured sum: Over-insurance is a common issue, where the policy covers more than what it would cost to rebuild the property, leading to unnecessarily high premiums.
- Excess levels: Low excesses can inflate premiums. Check whether increasing the voluntary excess could lower the overall cost.
- Claims history: If the block has a poor claims history, premiums may rise significantly. Request a copy of the claims record to understand why.
How Can Awareness Improve Decision-Making?
With rising service charges and scrutiny on leasehold practices across the UK, it’s more important than ever for leaseholders to be aware of their rights and responsibilities. Whether it’s pushing for better transparency, forming management groups, or using legal channels, knowledge is a powerful tool in keeping insurance costs fair.
For broader insights into leasehold issues, service charges, and market regulations, staying updated through reliable resources is key. The website UK Property Market News regularly covers stories on leaseholder rights, tribunal cases, and changes in insurance legislation, making it a valuable source for leaseholders looking to stay informed.
By being proactive, asking the right questions, and seeking accountability, leaseholders can avoid being unfairly burdened by insurance costs and ensure that every pound spent contributes real value.
Conclusion
Leaseholders have the power to take control of their insurance expenses by staying proactive and informed. Understanding the policy details, questioning excessive charges, and engaging with fellow leaseholders can help prevent overpaying for unnecessary coverage.
By challenging unfair costs and ensuring transparency in the process, leaseholders can protect their finances while maintaining the integrity of their property management.
Making informed choices and taking collective action are essential steps toward fairer and more accountable insurance practices in the leasehold sector.
Latest posts by Anna Smith (see all)
- How Can Leaseholders Ensure They Are Not Paying for Unnecessary Insurance Costs? - September 28, 2025
- Rubbish Items Can be Reused - October 26, 2021
- Why Virtual Magicians Are Best For Kids? - August 21, 2021
